LSE Logo

How Ministries of Finance can build capabilities for economic analysis and modeling to drive green and resilient transitions

LSE Logo

Taking stock of challenges, strategies, and lessons learned

Throughout the Coalition of Finance Ministers for Climate Action’s Helsinki Principle 4 initiative ‘Economic Analysis for Green and Resilient Transitions’, a clear message emerges: Ministries of Finance are engaged, interested, and aware of the transition—but many still lack the analytical capabilities they need to lead it.  

The HP4 Capabilities Report provides an overview of strategies, options, and recommendations for how Ministries of Finance can practically enhance their analytical capabilities to drive green and resilient transitions. Among the report’s key messages are: 

  • Capability is about more than having access to suitable tools and models. It is about being able to identify, use and maintain tools and conduct (or commission) analysis to answer relevant policy questions, communicating results (and limitations), and ensuring integration into decision-making processes.
  • Ministries of Finance have different levels of analytical capabilities. These have a substantial impact on the type of analysis that could be most suitable and worth investing in, and the priorities and next steps for strengthening local capabilities. Approaches for building capabilities should be pragmatic and build on existing capabilities. It is better to ‘start simple’ and refine the analysis throughout than to wait for more expertise to arrive.
  • Ministries of Finance can build or improve their capabilities over time. This typically requires:
    – Skills: Building analytical capabilities requires ensuring dedicated staffing resources with the right mix of skills for conducting or interpreting modeling and analysis are present in the Ministry.
    – Collaboration: Ministries of Finance cannot address their capability gaps alone. They may require support from a broader analytical ecosystem, including line ministries and government agencies willing to share models, data, and experience; universities and research institutes with climate expertise; and technical assistance providers and the wider international community, which can help build expertise and improve access to tools and data.
    – Governance: Clear roles, responsibilities, and institutional structures are crucial for ensuring that climate-related economic modeling and analysis are effectively integrated into the Ministry of Finance’s decision-making. 

There is a strong demand for technical assistance providers to ramp up and reform existing offers and training provision to help Ministries of Finance develop and maintain internal capabilities. This will require working with universities, research institutions, and partners across government.  

 

CITED CONTRIBUTIONS
Australia – Department of the Treasury

Re-establishing the Australian Treasury’s climate modeling capability

Rebecca Cassells and Gerard Hawkins
Australia – Department of the Treasury

Estimating the impact of selected physical climate risks on the Australian economy

Freya Carlton, Rebecca Cassells, Rebecca Colquhoun,…
Canada – Department of Finance

Finance Canada CGE model

Coalition for Capacity on Climate Action (C3A)

Financing the transition: how can Ministries of Finance build sustainable financial strategies and what analytical tools do they need?

Sebastian Valdecantos, Richard Nikiema and Hannah…
Coalition of Finance Ministers for Climate Action

Capability Assessment Framework (CAF): a new self-assessment tool to empower Ministries of Finance to build capabilities to mainstream and drive climate action

Biden Administration – Council of Economic Advisors (CEA)/Office of Management and Budget (OMB), Executive Office of the President of the United States (EOP)

The United States’ efforts to account for climate-related financial risk to the federal budget

Danish Research Institute for Economic Analysis and Modelling (DREAM)

The GreenREFORM model

Deutsche Gesellschaft für Internationale Zusammenarbeit (GIZ)

Modeling climate-resilient economic development: GIZ’s approach to supporting sustainable economic growth

Naima Abdulle, Sebastian Homm, Christian Fischle,…
Environment for Development Initiative

EfD—a global research network combining research, academic training, training of civil servants, and advisory to inform policy

Finland - Prime Minister's Office

Strengthening capabilities to undertake economic impact assessments of climate strategies and impacts: the Finnish experience

Dr. Saara Tamminen and Pekka Moren
International Monetary Fund (IMF) Fiscal Affairs Department

The critical role of Ministries of Finance for investment in adaptation and the analytical principles and tools available

Emanuele Massetti, Senior Economist, Fiscal Affairs…
Institute for New Economic Thinking at the Oxford Martin School

Time series models for forecasting technological change, particularly for energy technologies: approaches relevant to Ministries of Finance

J. Doyne Farmer
International Growth Centre – Rwanda Office

The use of climate–economy models in Rwanda’s Ministry of Finance and public institutions: the challenges in building analytical capability

Italy - Ministry of Economy and Finance

The Italian Ministry of Economy and Finance climate-related modeling tools: how to build a flexible suite of models serving different purposes

Mexico – Ministry of Finance

Assessing the fiscal risks of physical climate change

NDC Partnership

Unpacking options for Ministries of Finance to leverage modeling and economic analysis to accelerate climate action

Joaquim Leite (Head of Climate Finance),…

Summary of emerging and new approaches to modeling the economic case for climate action: lessons from New Climate Economy for Ministries of Finance and future model development agenda

Leonardo Garrido, SILIEN (former lead economist,…
Sierra Leone – Ministry of Finance

Climate policy priorities in Sierra Leone

Switzerland - Federal Department of Finance

Modeling the fiscal impacts of the net zero target within fiscal sustainability analysis

Benjamin Lerch, Thomas Brändle, and Martin…
University of East Anglia

Methodological recommendations for Ministries of Finance on climate change risk assessment and the enhancement of damage functions

Rachel Warren
Biden Administration – U.S. Department of the Treasury

Economic impact assessment of the Inflation Reduction Act (IRA)

World Bank

Data sources for the macro-modeling of climate change impacts and policies

Heather Ruberl, Economist; Pascal Saura, Senior…
World Bank/International Monetary Fund (IMF) Fiscal Affairs Department

The Climate Policy Assessment Tool (CPAT)

World Resources Institute (WRI)

Informing economic modeling approaches for effective climate transitions

Vanessa Pérez-Cirera (Global Economics Director), Luis…
World Resources Institute (WRI)/SOAS University of London - Resilience Adaptation Mainstreaming Program (RAMP)

Resilience Adaptation Mainstreaming Program (RAMP): building capacity at Ministries of Finance through local universities

Carter Brandon and Ulrich Volz